Question:
An underlying theme in the film is the issue of white racism and how this racism has spawned fear. Using specific examples from the film as well as other research, agree or disagree with the concept that racism in our country leads to fear.
Response:
In the film, Bowling for Columbine Michael Moore examines the causes in which could have lead to the disastrous event that played out at Columbine High School in the form of a school shooting. One of these causes that Moore outlines heavily is the media and how they transform racism with their power into fear. Within the film, Moore interviews Marilyn Manson who makes the clever realization that media produces fear in order for consumption to happen. An example of this theory would be how toothpaste advertisers utilize the fear of having bad teeth and bad breath which causes people to reject you, for their customers to buy their product. The fear that these advertisers inspire within the watchers of their commercials causes the audience to question their own teeth and become worried and afraid that they do not match the “standards”. Nevertheless, the fear of bad breath is not the only thing that the media inspires.
The media also inspires feelings of racism towards the minority groups of the US. Moore then continues to state that it is the racist images that are seen on the news and within America’s past that has contributed to this fear and lead to the increased use of weapons within the States. Within the section of the movie entitled “A Brief History of America” (which can be see here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPBHtjZmSpw ) the little bullet mascot outlines how fear is what has driven Americans to where they are now, a fear-inspired, foreign-hating nation. Moore further develops this idea by showing multiple news reels where the culprit of the crimes is a non-white male. Moore discusses the idea that children and people of all ages, are exposed to this and begin to associate negative ideas and crime with all people who are not white.
One of the people interviewed by Moore states “if it bleeds, it leads”. This is in relation to how news companies select the stories that they will headline and use in their newspapers, television programs, etc. Moore states the interesting statistic that when the murder rate went down 20% the coverage that these murders received increased. The media amplifies the fear or a man/woman of a different ethnic background then us is going to try to come and kill us.
This irrational fear that has been blown out of proportion within the United States, is what causes people to want to buy guns in order to protect themselves. The racism that is present in the country and amplified by the media creates fear.
From Rodney Green’s anaylsis of Bowling for Columbine (which can be found here http://mindprod.com/politics/bowling.html), he identifies other possible causes of this racial fear from the movie including:
- The USA was the only western country to historically make extensive use of slaves. Descendants of slave owners inherit the family attitude of fear of blacks.
- The USA was the only western country that historically “recently” killed large numbers of indigenous people. Descendants of pioneers inherit the paranoia of those involved in the massacres.
- The USA’s TV news and reality TV is the most violent of any country. Adrenalin keeps the ratings up. People come to believe they live in a world far more dangerous than it actually is.
- The USA is the dominant economic and military power on the planet. Americans have the normal paranoia of the wealthy that others are just itching to take it all away.
- The USA had a period of prohibition which lead to the rise of the Mafia, and a glorification of the mob in pop culture. Mob morality leaked into everyday life. Prohibition provided high profits to the rum runners. A shot could go for $3 where prior to prohibition it was only a few cents. The need for transporting and warehousing large amounts of liquor forced criminals to co-operate. They had co-ordinate the bribing of thousands of officials. Criminals had to get organised.
- The USA has a much stricter prohibition on drugs than other countries do. Other countries focus more on harm reduction, treatment and education. The resulting high profits stimulate violent turf wars between drug dealers.
- America is the most Christian western nation. It tends to favour fundamentalist denominations that teach God is cruel, vengeful and violent. Right wingers generally are doing most of the shooting. They learn the notion of violent retribution from the pulpit.
- Americans have a love affair with the automobile. Most of the rest of the world don’t use automobiles to anywhere near the same extent, even when they own them. Americans isolated in their cars don’t rub shoulders with the same people day after day the way people in other cultures do. The car lets an American range over a huge territory each day. The automobile means Americans tend to live in a world mainly populated by total strangers. There is a natural primate distrust of strangers.
- The USA has the 2nd Amendment which gives a constitutionals right to “bear arms”. Americans tie gun ownership to virtue and patriotism more than anyone else. They are much more emotional about guns.
- Protection of property is extremely important to Americans. It morally, if not legally, justifies killing a suspected thief. People in other countries tend to value life above property even the life of a burglar. People often kill family members mistaking them for burglars.
- The USA is the most laissez faire capitalist of the western democracies. I develop this idea later.
- Young Americans often enlist or are drafted into military service. Part of the training for this is boot camp, a type of brainwashing where recruits are taught unquestioning obedience to authority. They are also taught to kill perfect strangers on command. There need be no reason at all for the murder.
Nevertheless, all of the facts presented by Michael Moore cannot be taken as 100% as fact. To see the flaws within Moore’s Bowling for Columbine see http://www.hardylaw.net/Truth_About_Bowling.html




